Comments from the "Ode to Star Trek"Design Contest 2009:

• Judge 01
  • Reeku - This is a humorous piece that just missed the mark for me. Perhaps it was too far a stretch to combine the "Got Milk?" commercials with the Star Trek universe, or maybe it was just that it was too obvious. Beyond that, I think this interpretation of Snowbuni looks a little too human for my taste. I react more positively to the cartoony versions. Last but not least, the see-through lettering behind the robot & tribbles made them appear incorporeal. Better, I think, to have left them entirely behind the characters and above the horizon line.
  • I present this entry the Quadrotriticale award for cross-pollination.
    
• Judge 02
  • Got Tribbles? Not a humorous piece - it does catch the eye with its layout of our heroine up to her... buried in tribbles.
  • Whister is apparently sorting the tribbles by color and size. Only niggling I'd point out is more contrast or separation between the artwork and the 'Got Tribbles?' would be nice.
• Discussion: Contest Time! Ode to Star Trek QUICKY Contest in the Pseudo Comments forum